The Memoir Club, Stanhope, UK, 2007, ISBN 978-1-84104-175-9,
230pp
For the first
time, the story of the great era of soil survey in developing
countries has been told. It begins with the pioneers between the
two World Wars: Fred Hardy, who taught generations of intending
Agricultural Officers sin the West Indies; Arthur Hornby in Nyasaland
(Malawi); Geoffrey Milne, who invented the catena concept, and
produced a reconnaissance soil map covering three countries of
East Africa; the ecologist, Colin Trapnell in Northern Rhodesia
(Zambia); and the earliest soil surveyor of local origin in the
tropics, A. W. R. Joachim in Ceylon (Sri Lanka). These were remarkable
men, working in isolation, who made first appraisals of the land
resources vast areas.
Land resource
survey reached its peak with the strengthened focus on development
in the post-war period, 1950-1975. Work was carried out initially
by soil surveyors in Colonial Departments of Agriculture. Later,
after independence, their work was taken over by the UK Government's
Land Resources Division. Over a 25-year period reconnaissance
surveys were completed, covering the greater part of Britain's
former overseas territories, in Africa, Asia, Central and South
America, and the Pacific.. At the same time an All-India Soil
Survey was established, which continues its mammoth task to this
day.
Keen young
men set off into the bush, the jungle, or the desert. The author
was one of these, constituting the Soil Survey of Nyasaland (Malawi)
from 1958 to 1962. With air photographs at their disposal, often
employing the land systems approach, they travelled on foot or
by Land Rover. In writing this book he draws on personal recollections
from over 90 former colleagues. Biographies of some of these are
given, such as the C. F. Charter of the Gold Coast (Ghana), known
for speaking his mind - and getting his way; foreign nationals,
including ex-prisoners of war, who joined British government service,
like Stanislav Radwanski and Willem Verboom; and the giants of
our time, Hugh Brammer, who dedicated his life's work to Ghana,
Zambia, and Pakistan, and is still active at the age of 80. Experiences
in the field, sometimes bizarre, some showing mistakes that can
be made by Europeans new to the tropics, lighten the text. It
is illustrated by period photographs.
The final chapter,
Retrospective, carries lessons for development planning by governments
and aid agencies at the present day. It argues that the current
swing in the direction of emphasis on socio-economic aspects has
gone to far, and a more balanced approach, in which the potential
of the land is matched against the needs of the people, is required.
Although the accounts of
surveys contain technical material, the book is highly readable
by the non-specialist. It forms a contribution to the history
of science, colonial history, geography, and development studies.
* * * * *
Thin on the Ground by
Anthony Young, 230 pages, 23 photographs, ISBN 978 1 84104 175
9, was published in 2007 by The Memoir Club, Durham, UK, priced
at £14.50 / US $ 30.00. It can be ordered online from www.thememoirclub.co.uk
by telephone on 0191 3735660, or through bookshops.